Former 'Banner' publisher ordered to pay IRS millions in taxes, penalties

Wednesday, February 29, 2012 at 11:16am

Former Nashville Banner publisher Irby Simpkins has admitted defeat in his running battle with the IRS and was ordered to pay more than $5 million in back taxes and $1.8 million in penalties by a U.S. Tax Court in November. He declined to say whether he has paid the sum.

Simpkins confirmed to The City Paper that he invested in a series of transactions on the advice of his accounting firm Price Waterhouse in the late 1990s. The IRS claimed that there were deficiencies in four different tax years, 1996-1999. In the largest of those years, 1998, Simpkins was found to have underpaid his taxes by nearly $4.7 million.

In February 1998, Simpkins and his partner Brownlee Currey took $65 million from the rival Tennessean and Gannett to make their paper, the Banner, go away. Simpkins’ final proceeds from the sale, approximately $20 million, generated a large tax liability.

Beginning in the early 2000s, Congress, the Treasury Department and the IRS began cracking down on foreign investment programs like the ones Simpkins was involved in. Price Waterhouse, now Pricewaterhouse Coopers, KPMG and several other firms would later settle over billions in unpaid taxes sheltered by schemes marketed variously as FLIP, OPIS, BOSS and Son of BOSS.

Simpkins says that after fighting the IRS for 10 years, an “old retired fella” had to move on.

“[The IRS] drug their feet and drug their feet and never came down with any conclusion because they were trying to prove criminal action against the partners at KPMG. I was just the tail on the dog on that one,” he said. “I went for 10 years without being able to have my case heard. Well, in that 10 years, the IRS spent a lot of money investigating, not only my transaction — I was almost a nonentity — but investigating over 700 taxpayers nationwide. They settled with the accounting firms for fairly nominal fees in exchange for the accounting firms furnishing the names of all of their clients that they had recommended these investments to and had made those investments. And so the reality was that after 10 years, it was insane for me, at 68, to continue with this kind of worry and frustration and not be able to deal with the Internal Revenue [Service]. At that time my attorney and I decided the best thing to do was just settle this.”

Simpkins’ penalties were doubled from 20 percent to 40 percent as the IRS found the case to be a gross valuation overstatement.

The sale of the Banner left Nashville with just one remaining daily newspaper, something Simpkins said he regrets. He told The City Paper that there was a local buyer who was interested in purchasing the afternoon paper, but that Gannett’s deal was the best.

“We had some offers. But when you're in a joint operating agreement, there's only one buyer, that's your partner,” Simpkins said. “And let me say this about Gannett — they didn't leverage that against us. They paid fair value for what we had to sell, which was wonderful.”

Simpkins also said that another publicly held publishing company was interested in purchasing the Banner but declined to name it.

14 Comments on this post:

By: sharko20 on 2/29/12 at 10:22

Obama says "thank you" for paying your fair share..............

By: TRHJR on 2/29/12 at 10:37

Well, Mr. Simpkins that was your choise ...... Damn look what crap we have now ....every news outlet TV & PRINT ... are commies ....

By: Jughead on 2/29/12 at 10:55

Gannett is the absolute worst "news" organization in the country. Nothing but a bunch of uneducated, snarky, illiterate liberal activists proclaiming to be journalists.

By: Rasputin72 on 2/29/12 at 11:45

Irby has mellowed quite a bit since he married Muriel Robinson. I would imagine that Muriel has a lot to do with getting him to look at this situation with more reality than he normally uses.

By: localboy on 2/29/12 at 1:35

Set and match, Rasputin.

By: govskeptic on 2/29/12 at 2:44

Does the Ex-wife have to return part of her divorce settlement in order to
pay what would be her half of this tax bill? Seems only fair!

By: localboy on 2/29/12 at 2:53

hahahahaha

By: JayBee56 on 3/3/12 at 4:47

It was a sad day when Nashville lost a such a formidable newspaper. All for money.

By: burberry outlet shop on 3/6/12 at 5:12

Coach Outlet Online is now the primary American marketer of components produced Christian Louboutin Outlet with the top leathers as nicely as other finest fabrics. Each cheap coach bags and every merchandise is belonging to the greatest superior and produced utilizing only the top materials. Each and every gucci handbags merchandise has generally insisted on hand-made and handworked. Coach Outlet Store Online has might be discovered being most desired add-ons for grownup women. Coach Factory Outlet Online would make them the complete alter in glimpse of new out merely close to towards styles, styles and colours to select from Coach Outlet Online. You do possess a opportunity to take a look at Coach Factory Outlet. Dealing with increasing demands of Cheap Supra Shoes and Tory Burch Sale, extra and extra Tory Burch Outlet supplements are accessible and accessible within the lowest price ferragamo sale. Welcome to order on our Tory Burch Shoes! People these occasions Gucci outlet require these excellent perfect good quality Supra Shoes Sale, but furthermore very much extra emphasis round one of the most efficient good quality of remarks a particular amount of Coach handbags from coach outlet store online. Maybe you also interested in our other cheap ferragamo shoes and gucci backpack. Welcome to choose your favorite items ferragamo outlet.

By: burberry outlet shop on 3/6/12 at 5:13

ティンバーランド ブーツ!激安価格で人気ブランド ティンバーランド通販、クラシックブーツ、ティンバーランドロールトップブーツ、子供靴など数多くの新作アイテムを展開。1918年より創業、長い歴史を持つティンバーランド
Timberlandブーツに対する企業理念は、世界的に知られるようになった現在でも高く掲げられています。ティンバーランド 靴そうした目的を実現させるための商品作りに全員が取り組んでおり、2008年には、timberlandエシスフィア誌「世界で最も倫理観の高い企業」ランキングにランクインしています。ティンバーランド 激安アメリカのボストンで1952年に設立されたカジュアル用品のメーカーです。会社設立までのTimberland ロールトップの歴史もとても古く、Timberland ロールトップの創始者であるネイサンシュワーツ氏が、ボストンの靴店でティンバーランド ロールトップを作りはじめたところからとなります。5本指シューズ ビブラムは、工業デザイナーのロバートフリーリにより考案され、ティンバーランド 6インチ1936年に最初の登山用のゴム底を発明したビブラム社の創設者である、ヴィターレブラマーニの孫である、マルコブラマーニに提案された。ビブラム ファイブフィンガーズセーリング情熱を燃やすマルコブラマーニはあたかも手袋のようで、ビブラム 販売店第二の皮膚のような感覚の靴のアイデアに魅了された。vibram fivefingers[ファイブフィンガーズ]は、優れた機敏性、バランス、コントロールを向上させる一方、五本指シューズ ビブラム戦場の危険な艤装や障害物からもブラマーニ氏の足をしっかりと守った。Vibram 5本指 シューズセーラーとして、靴産業界のベテランとしての経験を生かし、ブラマーニ氏はフリーリ氏と共に、5本指シューズビブラムソールの守られた裸足のセンセーションを提供する今日の形状をした最初のビブラム 5本指を完成させた。clarks レディースクラッシック、ユニーク、今までなかった斬新なフォルムクラークス 靴...けれども時代とともに定番になってゆく靴クラークス アウトレット。時代がめまぐるしく移り変わってゆく中で、流行に追随することなく、しかし、つねに時代のこころに溶けこんできた靴たちが“クラークス オリジナルズ”。クラークス 通販“クラークス オリジナルズ”が長年皆様にご愛用いただいているのには、モノ作りに対して丁寧に向きあい、clarks 激安常に独創的なアイディアを靴づくりに入れ込んできたからと考えています。クラークス 店舗どれをとっても、そのデビュー時には「こんな奇妙な靴なんて!!」と失笑をかったデザイン。clarks 格安人に笑われようとも、クラークス オリジナルズは クラークス レディース履き心地の良い靴をつくりたいその信念を貫いて靴づくりを続けてきました。

By: burberry outlet shop on 3/6/12 at 5:14

ナイキ air max 95を買うならエアマックス 95。ナイキエアマックス(NIKE AIR MAX)激安通販ショップ、エアマックス2012を格安価格で販売します!ナイキ エアマックス2012往年のランニングシューズファンを思わず唸らせてしまうエアマックス2011モデルが 海外限定で復刻! ナイキエアマックス 2009を代表する名機、テイルウィンド。 ナイキ エアマックス クラシック92年に発売されたオリジナルモデルそのままの素材とナイキ エアマックス 2011カラーリン グナイキ エアマックス 2009。 特徴的なエアマックス 360アッパーデザインやソールデザイン、ナイキエアマックス360 そしてタンロゴは当 時のままエアマックス 90。 オールド感あるデザインと適度なボリューム感が魅力のモデルエアマックス 2010。 スニーカーエアマックス 97が面白かったエアマックス1、新作が発売されるのナイキ エアマックスが待ち遠しかった「 あの時代」を代表するエアマックス 2003モデル。 2009年、独特の存在感を漂わせて復刻エアマックスです!

By: foxin on 4/6/12 at 8:54

La tendance la plus en vogue du c?té." casque dr dre Son utilisation audacieuse de la couleur et le design de mode, ainsi que la bénédiction de célébrité, Casque Beats et il a beaucoup souffert des jeunes de tous ages. Casque de Monster poussez la base, Casque Monster Beats ils ont tendance à les amateurs de hi-fi peut être dé?u. casque dr dre est d'abord développé dans le monde de haute énergie des appareils vidéo et sonore pour se connecter la marque, Casque Monster Beats la société a été fondée en 1979 par M. Lee Mi Saint (Mr.Noel Lee), un américain d'origine chinoise. beats by dre powerbeats Avant de cet équipement, audio, en dépit de l'émergence de la haute fidélité, beats by dre la qualité sonore très bonne platine tourne-disque vinyles, Salut niveau de la fin de l'amplificateur, beats by dre studio et de la musique pour rétablir la parfaite haute-fidélité haut-parleur, mais la connexion de ces appareils La ligne savait rien, monster beats dr dre il suffit d'utiliser un fil ordinaire pour transmettre haute-fidélité du signal. Aimez la musique, aiment jouer avec les équipements audio. Dans la pratique, il va produire un son différent avec du fil différent de connecter un appareil audio, casque monster beats créée par la conductivité des fils et un peu de performance excellente transmission, créant ainsi une nouvelle industrie. Et les gens connaissent l'importance du fil dans le système de sonorisation.

By: foxin on 4/6/12 at 8:54

Approche de Louis Vuitton Sacs est d'insister sur la conduite de leur propre marque, adhérer à l'esprit de sa propre marque, faire la même chose, à fournir quelques petites choses vraies culturelles, il est à espérer que Louis Vuitton Pas Cher a plus à comprendre la Louis Vuitton des gens de faire attention aux produits sac louis vuitton, pas de pouvoir d'achat, mais cette prise de conscience des consommateurs ou de préoccupation pour le produit de la culture, pourrait un jour avoir la possibilité de choisir sera la première fois à Choisissez Vuitton Sac 2012. Un siècle plus tard, imprimée avec un motif unique de "louis vuitton pas cher" sac en toile monogramme logo, avec une richesse de la légendaire et d'Athènes devenu un classique de la mode. 100 ans, Louis Vuitton Sacs le monde a connu de nombreux changements, la poursuite et les idées esthétiques du peuple sera également changé, mais louis vuitton sac n'est pas seulement la réputation de Zoran, et maintient désormais un charme unique.

By: foxin on 4/6/12 at 8:55

Find right here louboutin shoes,Nearly red sole shoes each of the citizens know a Louboutin Shoes On sale thing about Christian Louboutin through the minimize world.Equally shaped the distinctive qualities of louboutin selling and Christian Christian Louboutin Cheap Shoes red bottom heels are nicely regarded Signature red lone and high heels.Today, cheapest shoes online it is unquestionable that just about every woman desires to attire the best.Therefore,in add-on red bottom shoes to dresses,they glance for some applicable accessories,make-up and red bottom shoes.However,to uncover garments christian louboutin outlet and make-up is regarded really easy.But,finding a comfy and beautiful pair of shoes may be really an adventure.Today,cheap louboutin shoes is regarded getting amid the red bottom sale extremely most beneficial loubiton shoes add-ons for females by just about every stylist. http://www.buychristianlouboutinoutlet.com