Jameson looks to hold off Bell, Byrd in Democratic judgeship primary

Sunday, March 4, 2012 at 10:05pm

In Mike Jameson’s lone TV spot boasting his credentials for judge, the ex-Metro councilman’s two sons flip through posters that highlight big-name supporters: former Mayor Bill Purcell, Councilwoman Megan Barry and Councilman Jerry Maynard are reeled off first.

The list of local politicos keeps going: council members Ronnie Steine, Charlie Tygard and Tim Garrett, school board chair Gracie Porter, state Reps. Mike Stewart and Mike Turner, state Sen. Joe Hayes, and so on.

Indeed, when a General Sessions judgeship opened following the death of Judge Leon Ruben, a few of these folks and other council friends pulled through to catapult him to the bench. After winning a special appointment by collecting 24 council votes, Jameson was sworn in as judge in November.   

Now, with the Democratic primary for General Sessions, Division 8, set for Tuesday, March 6, Jameson must prove he can claim the same judgeship through the support of Nashville voters — not just those in his home turf of Lockeland Springs and Edgefield, but countywide. He’s hoping Nashvillians recall his eight years of council service fondly, and see his temperament and approach as positives in the courtroom.

“It’s important to have a judge who maintains a sense of humility and fairness,” Jameson, a longtime favorite among local progressives, told The City Paper. “I think I’ve received good marks for those qualities during my service on the council, so I think you can anticipate that I would continue the same tradition as a judge. I think I’ve done that in my tenure to date as judge.”  

Jameson's two opponents, Rachel Bell and Jack Byrd, however, seem to be taking subtle swipes at Jameson’s arrival to the bench, casting him as a political insider as they make their separate cases for the judgeship.

Whichever of the three emerges victorious Tuesday will be heavy favorites to knock off independent candidate Michael Rowan in August.

Bell, 34, was among a handful of attorneys who applied for the special judicial appointment in the fall but lost out to Jameson. “I’m not a part of the establishment,” she said of receiving zero council votes back then. She added: “I didn’t know the council would appoint based upon relationships versus what the community and their constituents would need as a whole for Davidson County.”

“I can understand that,” Bell said, continuing her thoughts on Jameson’s appointment via connections. “That’s human nature.”

Byrd, a 53-year-old attorney who didn’t run for the council appointment, boasts the following on his campaign website: “Let Experience, NOT Politics, Work for You.” The message seems like a slight jab at Jameson’s political past, though Byrd insists that isn’t his intention.

“It is what it is,” Byrd said of his slogan. “It’s not about being elected somewhere to me. It’s about being a judge in General Sessions. That’s where I’ve worked. That’s where I’ve always worked. That’s where I’m at almost everyday. I’m the only candidate in the race that actually works in those dockets.”

Byrd is referring to the General Sessions criminal court dockets. According to legal records, neither Bell nor Jameson has made recent appearances in criminal court, while Byrd’s appearances exceed hundreds of pages and total thousands. Byrd has built his candidacy on this fact. 

“The judge’s bench is not the place for a learning curve,” Byrd said.

Regarding civil cases heard in Davidson County General Sessions Court, Jameson has made 46, his last appearance in 1999; Byrd has made 21; and Bell has made more than 90. In some instances, Bell was representing herself after suing clients who failed to deliver her legal fees.

Jameson believes those figures should be put into perspective. His opponents have been licensed lawyers since 2005. He has 22 years of legal experience, he points out. He began as a public defender in 1990 working in General Sessions. He then moved onto other courts.

“That’s a fairly selective window that completely ignores my experience as a public defender in General Sessions Court in the 1990s, and erroneously assumes that experience in higher courts is worthless,” Jameson said of attempts to criticize him for a lack of General Sessions criminal case practice.  

 

 

The three candidates are vying for one of 11 judicial seats in General Sessions, a high-volume court that hears cases ranging from civil, misdemeanor and felony charges to environmental, traffic and Metro ordinance violations. Some lawyers liken General Sessions to a “cattle call.” Hundreds of cases go before the judge daily.

Bell, a partner at Bell & Kinslow for seven years, is both the only African-American and the only female candidate of the bunch. In an interview with The City Paper, she pointed out that Davidson County’s General Sessions is decidedly white and male. Only one of the court’s 11 judges is black, and only three are women.

“I’ll be able to bring diversity to the court,” said Bell, who likely needs a high black turnout to win Tuesday. “Both of my counterparts are male. They’re Caucasian, so they wouldn’t bring that diversity to the bench.”

“Our community is diverse,” she said. “We’ve got individuals from all different walks of life that live here. To only have one African-American judge, I believe it’s very important for us to start opening up the doors and having other experiences on the bench as well.”

In her legal work, Bell listed experience in General Sessions, Chancery and federal courts in a candidates’ questionnaire. She said she’s known best for her representing people dealing with home foreclosures. Bell’s law office is the only one in Bordeaux, she said, thus opening herself up to a variety of different cases.

“I’m committed to the community,” Bell said.

Byrd, who opened a private firm in Nashville in 2005, said his firm works primarily in General Sessions, with “90 to 95 percent” of his caseload focused on criminal law. Byrd said he has sat in as a special judge “a couple of hundred times” collectively in 10 of the General Sessions Courts, including the late Ruben’s courtroom.

“I’m the only candidate in the race that’s one of the 10 members that are approved to be substitute judges in General Sessions,” Byrd said.

“General Sessions courts are 80 to 90 percent criminal [cases],” Byrd said. “If you want to be a General Sessions judge, you ought to work in General Sessions.”

Byrd boasts military and law enforcement experience. Some courthouse observers, however, have noted Byrd’s curious voting history for someone running in a Democratic primary. Byrd voted in state Republican primaries in 2002, 2004, 2006 and 2010. During that time he voted in two county Democratic primaries.

“I vote for who I believe is the best person for the job,” Byrd said in response. “My personal opinion is judicial races should be nonpartisan.”

By every metric, this contest is Jameson’s race to lose. Buoyed by his well-known backers, Jameson’s $88,000 campaign war chest — which includes a $33,000 personal loan — is greater than the combination of his opponents’ fundraising totals. Jameson is the only candidate who has won elections in the past, and he has the highest name recognition. 

On top of those factors, a Nashville Bar Association poll of its members gave the highest marks to Jameson. Forty-nine percent of 1,062 respondents said they “highly recommended” Jameson for the judgeship, compared to 7 percent for Bell and Byrd. Of the three, Jameson received the fewest number of “do not recommend” responses — just 6 percent. Twenty percent of respondents did not recommend Bell, and 15 percent did not recommend Byrd.

If Jameson were to win the election, many speculate he could run for a different judgeship down the road. In 2008, he sought a circuit court judge position, but then-Gov. Phil Bredesen appointed Joe P. Binkley Jr. instead. Jameson rejected those ambitions. 

“This is the fulfillment of a dream since I’ve been 8 years old,” Jameson said. “I don’t have any plans at all to go anywhere else ever.”

14 Comments on this post:

By: Nitzche on 3/5/12 at 8:05

Big name supporters?jerry(Disbarred) Maynard

By: Jughead on 3/5/12 at 12:50

Ms. Bell---we don't need any more dang "diversity"....we need "quality" regardless of skin color.

Way to throw the race card.

By: nashville1950tk on 3/5/12 at 1:56

Nashville1951tk
Jughead, diversity is important and is needed here in Davidson County. Reading the article you can tell, Ms. Bell isn't pulling the race card. Jameson is still trying to get the edge, by trying to make it seem like she is not qualified. She is not only qualified but will bring diversity to the bench. When you talk to Ms. Bell she only talks about her experience and hard work. It is the paper that keeps talking about she is african-american and female. Looks like Garrison pulled the race card, not Ms. Bell. Byrd and Bell are experienced and have worked in the court, Jameson has not. He hasn't worked there in over 13 years.

By: burberry outlet shop on 3/6/12 at 5:07

Coach Outlet Online is now the primary American marketer of components produced Christian Louboutin Outlet with the top leathers as nicely as other finest fabrics. Each cheap coach bags and every merchandise is belonging to the greatest superior and produced utilizing only the top materials. Each and every gucci handbags merchandise has generally insisted on hand-made and handworked. Coach Outlet Store Online has might be discovered being most desired add-ons for grownup women. Coach Factory Outlet Online would make them the complete alter in glimpse of new out merely close to towards styles, styles and colours to select from Coach Outlet Online. You do possess a opportunity to take a look at Coach Factory Outlet. Dealing with increasing demands of Cheap Supra Shoes and Tory Burch Sale, extra and extra Tory Burch Outlet supplements are accessible and accessible within the lowest price ferragamo sale. Welcome to order on our Tory Burch Shoes! People these occasions Gucci outlet require these excellent perfect good quality Supra Shoes Sale, but furthermore very much extra emphasis round one of the most efficient good quality of remarks a particular amount of Coach handbags from coach outlet store online. Maybe you also interested in our other cheap ferragamo shoes and gucci backpack. Welcome to choose your favorite items ferragamo outlet.

By: Nashvillesanity on 3/6/12 at 7:20

The fact Jack Byrd and Rachel Bell keep touting "experience" is laughable! As a lawyer who has practiced extensively in every level of our State Courts as well as Federal District Courts, saying, "I practice in General Sessions all the time" shows you are a small-time attorney.

First, criminal dockets are long, the same, and really only require the judge to (a) agree to a plea bargain, (b) occasionally preside over a small bench trial, or (c) bind the case over to Criminal Circuit Court and then it's out of their hands.

Civil General Sessions has a total limit of $25,000 for damages so it's effectively a daily local episode of Judge Judy and evictions for people who don't pay rent or their credit card bills.

Jack Byrd and Rachel Bell practice in General Sessions because it's not advanced legal work. Judge Jameson has practiced at a high level for 22 years doing advanced and complex commercial litigation.

Don't be fooled by the argument that "we've been mediocre our entire careers so we should be elected to the bench." Rather, trust the fact that there is only one lawyer who you would want to hire to represent you out of this group if you were in trouble, sued, or were pursing damages against someone else.

Judge Jameson is the obvious and clear choice.

By: Jughead on 3/6/12 at 8:57

@Nashvillesanity: I was going to vote for Jameson until I read your moronic post. Now, I will vote for Byrd. If you really are a lawyer, you are a giant dbag. Of course, that is an oxymoron.

By: Jughead on 3/6/12 at 10:21

I love Chinese people! Show me the money!

By: shinestx on 3/6/12 at 3:57

I voted for Bell because she is colored.

Jughead, a lawyer and a giant dbag???... that's actually redundant.

By: foxin on 4/6/12 at 8:54

La tendance la plus en vogue du c?té." casque dr dre Son utilisation audacieuse de la couleur et le design de mode, ainsi que la bénédiction de célébrité, Casque Beats et il a beaucoup souffert des jeunes de tous ages. Casque de Monster poussez la base, Casque Monster Beats ils ont tendance à les amateurs de hi-fi peut être dé?u. casque dr dre est d'abord développé dans le monde de haute énergie des appareils vidéo et sonore pour se connecter la marque, Casque Monster Beats la société a été fondée en 1979 par M. Lee Mi Saint (Mr.Noel Lee), un américain d'origine chinoise. beats by dre powerbeats Avant de cet équipement, audio, en dépit de l'émergence de la haute fidélité, beats by dre la qualité sonore très bonne platine tourne-disque vinyles, Salut niveau de la fin de l'amplificateur, beats by dre studio et de la musique pour rétablir la parfaite haute-fidélité haut-parleur, mais la connexion de ces appareils La ligne savait rien, monster beats dr dre il suffit d'utiliser un fil ordinaire pour transmettre haute-fidélité du signal. Aimez la musique, aiment jouer avec les équipements audio. Dans la pratique, il va produire un son différent avec du fil différent de connecter un appareil audio, casque monster beats créée par la conductivité des fils et un peu de performance excellente transmission, créant ainsi une nouvelle industrie. Et les gens connaissent l'importance du fil dans le système de sonorisation.

By: foxin on 4/6/12 at 8:54

Approche de Louis Vuitton Sacs est d'insister sur la conduite de leur propre marque, adhérer à l'esprit de sa propre marque, faire la même chose, à fournir quelques petites choses vraies culturelles, il est à espérer que Louis Vuitton Pas Cher a plus à comprendre la Louis Vuitton des gens de faire attention aux produits sac louis vuitton, pas de pouvoir d'achat, mais cette prise de conscience des consommateurs ou de préoccupation pour le produit de la culture, pourrait un jour avoir la possibilité de choisir sera la première fois à Choisissez Vuitton Sac 2012. Un siècle plus tard, imprimée avec un motif unique de "louis vuitton pas cher" sac en toile monogramme logo, avec une richesse de la légendaire et d'Athènes devenu un classique de la mode. 100 ans, Louis Vuitton Sacs le monde a connu de nombreux changements, la poursuite et les idées esthétiques du peuple sera également changé, mais louis vuitton sac n'est pas seulement la réputation de Zoran, et maintient désormais un charme unique.

By: foxin on 4/6/12 at 8:54

Find right here louboutin shoes,Nearly red sole shoes each of the citizens know a Louboutin Shoes On sale thing about Christian Louboutin through the minimize world.Equally shaped the distinctive qualities of louboutin selling and Christian Christian Louboutin Cheap Shoes red bottom heels are nicely regarded Signature red lone and high heels.Today, cheapest shoes online it is unquestionable that just about every woman desires to attire the best.Therefore,in add-on red bottom shoes to dresses,they glance for some applicable accessories,make-up and red bottom shoes.However,to uncover garments christian louboutin outlet and make-up is regarded really easy.But,finding a comfy and beautiful pair of shoes may be really an adventure.Today,cheap louboutin shoes is regarded getting amid the red bottom sale extremely most beneficial loubiton shoes add-ons for females by just about every stylist. http://www.buychristianlouboutinoutlet.com

By: lyj123 on 5/30/12 at 12:33

Dieses xprog-m Produkt hat aus China hergestellt.Der Preis ist unparteiisch.unsere Waren sind in ähnlicher Funktion wie Original-Ware.bitte aktualisieren nicht durch offizielle Website, falls ja, wird das Produkt gebrochen obd2 lexia 3 werden.Wenn Sie Upgrade-Funktion möchenten,wenden Sie sich bitte an uns,Wir schicken Ihnen die neueste Version Link.Windows-Betriebssystem Voraussetzung ist Windows XP-System
OBD2 Software lyj

By: wandybrad on 8/5/12 at 4:15

sac en toile monogramme logo, avec une richesse de la légendaire et d'Athènes devenu un classique de la mode
dissertation writing

By: xuexue on 8/27/12 at 3:31

repeated his call
[url=http://www.coachoutletba.org/]Coach Outlet Online[/url]
initially made Monday, for Mr. Akin to drop out. He said Mr. Akin’s comments were “offensive and wrong, and he should
Coach Outlet Online
very seriously consider what course would be in the best interest of our country.”
Coach Outlet Online
“Today, his fellow Missourians urged him to step aside,” Mr. Romney said, “and I think he should accept their counsel
Coach Outlet Online
it is a race their candidate can win, given that the Democratic incumbent, Claire McCaskill, has long been considered the
Coach Outlet Online
The fact is rape can lead to pregnancy