Mother sentenced to six years for death of 4-month-old son

Thursday, March 29, 2012 at 12:53pm
Staff reports
0329 ArnesaHart mug.jpg
Arnes’a Hart  

Arnes’a Hart, the 24-year-old woman who pleaded guilty earlier this year to criminally negligent homicide and child neglect, was sentenced Thursday to six years in jail for the death of her 4-month-old son.

A Davidson County grand jury indicted Hart last summer on charges of first-degree felony murder and two counts of child neglect after her youngest son, Sir Rodrick Polk-Donaldson, was found dead inside a room at a Music Valley Drive hotel on Feb. 20, 2011.

The investigation determined that Hart worked as a desk clerk at the hotel and had left her 3-year-old son and the Polk-Donaldson in one of the vacant rooms.

According to a spokeswoman for the district attorney’s office, testimony during the sentencing hearing revealed that the children were left unattended for a five-hour period. Investigators determined that the 3-year-old had rolled over onto the infant while sleeping and smothered the 4-month-old to death.

Both parties in the criminal case agreed to Hart’s six-year sentence. Thursday’s sentencing hearing was to determine whether that sentence would be served in jail or on probation.

6 Comments on this post:

By: jeffrey31 on 3/29/12 at 3:43

A very sad story. It seems likely to me that if this had happened at home this woman would not have faced such severe charges (felony first degree murder?!?). She could have been watching tv in the living room for a bit and left her kids asleep on the same bed, and the end result might be the same. I presume it doesn't take 5 hours to smother a child, so the frequency she checked on them might not (even probably not) have prevented it.

She made a bad decision here in leaving the children, one that will follow her all her life. But I also wonder the context of that decision. Maybe she couldn't afford child care, especially if she was a single mom working the night shift (full time care for two very small children can run well over $1500 month at a quality day care not including any premium for night time care, though there are somewhat cheaper options available. If she made $10/hour in her job, almost her entire salary for a month of work would be consumed by child care). Maybe her regular sitter cancelled at the last moment and she had no other option but to sneak the children into a vacant room than miss a day's work or even get fired if she had been absent too many times (infants get sick, need doctor's appointments, etc). Though there is a possibility she didn't care about her children and was truly negligent, she could have been doing the best she could in a very difficult situation. That doesn't absolve her of responsibility, but it puts her failure in perspective. I hope her lawyer tried to present a fuller set of facts to the jury than we get here.

By: jeffrey31 on 3/29/12 at 3:46

Well, strike the comments about the jury, but I still hope her lawyer presented a good case to the prosecutor in their plea bargain negotiations.

By: NewYorker1 on 3/30/12 at 8:24

So sad. What I don't understand is why someone would have children and can't afford it? Raising a child is very expensive and people need to start taking that into account before they decide to have children. There's no excuse these days with all the forms of birth control available. If you have a child these days, it's by choice. With that said, if you are can barely make it financially for yourself, then you should not be having kids. It's just that simple.

By: NewYorker1 on 3/30/12 at 8:31

I am constantly telling the youth in my family, both male and female, to choose a partner that is college educated, six-figured salary, excellent credit scores, no debt, in good physical and mental health before you get involved and especially before you get married and start a family. They need to know what type of family they come from and their family's financial situation too, because you don't want to marry someone who's family member will be asking for money and handouts all the damn time.

By: beachbabygirrl on 4/4/12 at 7:51

New Yorker, thanks for the laugh.

Wouldn't it be nice if everyone could find someone with a six figure income, no debt, excellent credit scores, great health, well guess what... You are delusional.

That is a great goal to strive for but chances are it's not going to happen.

The men your daughters grow up and marry, may already have a child. They may be divorced or widowed, they may work at a theme park making 9.00 an hour. They may have had to drop out of high school to support their family because his dad might have died young.

What I an trying to tell you is just because someone doesn't have a six figure income, has debt, student loans, medical bills, car payments, house payments, has a child from a previous relationship does not make them any less of a person than your "ideal" mate.
If you are going to dream, dream big but when you fall in love, nothing else matters.

By: 9445 on 5/9/12 at 6:50

Creating Secure Smooth Shoes or ecco mens outdoor shoes boots for women Convenient
Smooth shoes or boots are believed because the beloved shoes or boots at any time, however, not almost all secure smooth shoes or boots for girls are in reality secure. Not merely inside high heel pumps, but in addition we could find out several concerns once we are usually sporting smooth shoes or boots. Several concerns just like not comfortable experience inside the foot aspect, or perhaps applied rearfoot will be the frequent issues we need to confront. Essentially the most common difficulty could be applied ankles. The particular smooth shoes or ecco mens casual shoes boots again portion can caress our own rearfoot and present scuff about the outer skin. The thing is typically as the shoes or boots put on? big t suit flawlessly to your toes, so that it movements and also scuff the outer skin. A better solution will be incorporating any safety net to improve how big is the particular shoes or boots. In the event the safety net will be ecco mens biom shoes also thicker, next we could fall any smooth sponge or cloth, muscle or perhaps natural cotton. In the event the shoes or boots suit and also put on the outer skin and also no shift, next we all earned? big t acquire applied.
Yet another remedy because of this problem will be picking smooth shoes or boots which can be produced from smooth substance. Components just like plastic-type usually are do away with skin. The trick regarding secure smooth shoes or boots for girls will be picking a single together with plastic. When we have been picking smooth shoes or boots together with plastic privately elements, next we all will see the shoes or boots attached with our own ecco mens performance shoes toes flawlessly and also we all put on? big t must concern yourself with scuff. One more difficulty which could take place will be distress around the bottom aspect. A better solution will be picking secure smooth ecco men shoes shoes or boots for ecco shoes women together with extensive top portion. When we all can not uncover the ecco mens dress shoes secure shoes or boots and also extensive top portion won't fit our own style, then a remedy is with shoes or boots shrub. We could broaden how big is our own shoes ecco5xd1h8hj or boots, additionally leading part of the particular shoes or boots with all the application. Your approach, we could pick virtually any design of shoes or boots and also keep secure.
Not merely regarding go out, but in addition can easily smooth shoes or boots become used for the office. You'll find thus quite a few sophisticated yet specialist smooth shoes or boots fit our own functioning clothes. A number of the advised brand names regarding smooth shoes or boots are usually Eight Gulf, Adi ecco mens golf shoes Ballet, Diesel powered Apartments, Anne Klein and lots of other folks. We could get the choices on-line. When we have been ecco shoes sale purchasing on the web, make sure we all search for any lower price, thus we could ecco women shoes have the finest shoes or boots together with thus way less pricey value. Put on? big t neglect to test EdwardForrer. corp identification regarding fantastic smooth shoes or boots choices. Due to the fact we've identified the particular tips, next we could pick and also handle secure smooth shoes or boots for girls, so that it will get the subject since essentially the most secure sort of shoes or boots.