Post Politics: Nashville has shut up

Sunday, February 14, 2010 at 11:45pm
Brittney Gilbert and Mike Sechrist (photo by Chris Wage)

Last week, after nearly five years, a Nashville web institution was shuttered. Nashville is Talking, WKRN’s pioneering blog project, is no more.

The site debuted in May 2005 and quickly became a virtual meeting place for the burgeoning local blogosphere. WKRN’s then-general manager Mike Sechrist and consultant Terry Heaton had a unique idea to incorporate blogging into the station’s evolving newsroom.

But instead of thrusting a journalist upon the blogosphere as had been the custom within the MSM, WKRN instead recruited a blogger.

Brittney Gilbert, a waitress and freelance writer, was hired to blog full time from the newsroom. She scoured the blogosphere every day looking for posts from local Nashvillians, highlighting and aggregating the best of what she found. What she created was something truly unique — an authentic and organic virtual community. Not a community based on subject matter or a singular political viewpoint. The only common thread was its sense of place: Nashville.

A year after launching Nashville is Talking, WKRN also hired this humble correspondent to run a sister site of sorts called Volunteer Voters. So while my view of Nashville is Talking may not be objective, it is certainly intimate. Not only was I among NiT’s biggest fans since its inception, I was one of its guest bloggers and, eventually, a deskmate of its talented matriarch.

But in June of 2007, Gilbert resigned amid both controversy stirred on her blog and regime change at the station. To many of its readers, NiT died that day. While her successor, Christian Grantham, certainly did some interesting things with the site, his focus was divided among other WKRN duties. Without Gilbert, who lived and breathed NiT, it was simply soulless.

So when Grantham announced last week that he was leaving the station and that the show wouldn’t go on, I got nostalgic. The words of current WKRN GM Gwen Kinsey helped.

“[I]f digital technology is teaching us anything, it is that specific platforms, unique technologies and the next cool thing all are born, reach maturity, and fade or evolve in what feels like a nanosecond of time,” Kinsey wrote in the blog’s final post. “NIT is a quaint reminder of how we all got started. Now, we find ourselves using Twitter, Facebook and live streaming to enhance our connections with our viewers in ways that blogs do less and less. It’s time to move on.”

Her wording was thought-provoking. The implication is that the blog format itself is on the way out, not just NiT.

Frankly, there’s plenty of evidence to support that view. Some of the more colorful bloggers that gave WKRN’s blog its flavor have decamped. Blake Wylie, Rex L. Camino and Thursday Night Fever’s Mr. Roboto are all “retired.” Even Bill Hobbs shuttered his popular political blog after finishing his tenure at the Tennessee Republican Party. Instead, he’s embraced Twitter. Many former bloggers now spend more time on Twitter and Facebook sharing links and writing pithy text-message-style status updates than sitting down and composing thoughts any longer than 100 words.

It’s like blogs are going the way of literary novels.

But there can be middle ground. Not every old platform is on its way out, and not every new one will usher in the next media revolution. Maybe television stations don’t need blogs. Perhaps other social media tools can help crowd-source and disseminate stories just as well or better than blogs.

But still, WKRN had something very special. In a new media world where the natural gravity is toward niches, where news and entertainment consumers have the ability and the freedom to consume only what they choose, Gilbert created a place where readers were engaged and challenged.

Whether liberal or conservative, soccer moms or biker dads, whether they blogged about cooking or crocheting, Nashville is Talking was a must-visit destination for blog practitioners and readers alike. People didn’t return to have their pre-existing worldview validated. They came back because they wanted to see what their neighbors were thinking about.

While the days of consumers getting their news and entertainment from a few shared sources are gone, there is something to be said for sharing a common experience.

Nashville is Talking was the place for that, a central location where a diverse group of people sharing the same bit of virtual ground could come together to be pissed off and amused, enlightened and infuriated, touched and disturbed.

Some might call it quaint. Powerful is a better word for it. And Nashville, whether it was last week or almost three years ago, is worse off for its passing.

Visit Kleinheider at

9 Comments on this post:

By: bruingeek on 2/15/10 at 5:24

"Some might call it quaint. Powerful is a better word for it. And Nashville, whether it was last week or almost three years ago, is worse off for its passing."

Well said. The "quaint reminder" comment does sting a little. Nashville may not be talking anymore, but we can hope that local media is listening a little better.

By: govskeptic on 2/15/10 at 8:10

The networks and local broadcast stations need imput from the community
in some form or fashion other than just that picked up from the New York
Times and Washington Post . Sorry to see Nashville is Talking leave as
i enjoyed it very much!

By: crapanddrivel on 2/18/10 at 4:31

Quaint reminder, my ass. NiT was not a product of Nashville's blogger community, but was largely responsible for it. Many of us aspired to be aggregated, and posted daily to that end. I'm guessing I'm not the only one who regularly checked hit-counters and referral logs to see if we'd benefited from Brittney's links. As I recall, the blogroll on NiT grew exponentially in the months following its launch, and helped launch the careers of many talented and enduring bloggers, including this article's author, Mr. Kleinheider.

Oh, and by the way A.C., literary novels haven't gone away, we just read them on our Kindles. Someone still writes the content.

By: jack34 on 3/5/10 at 1:07

Post Politics: Nashville has shut up is a nice post. It looks that you are highly expert blogger. Your post is an excellent example of why I keep coming back to read your excellent quality content that is forever updated. Your all site is well managed and comprehensive. That was exactly what I needed to read today.
mcdst training

Thank you

By: MaricelaRoy18 on 7/13/11 at 8:37

If you are willing to buy a car, you would have to get the home loans. Moreover, my mother all the time takes a short term loan, which occurs to be really reliable.

By: RAYMONDFLOSSIE35 on 7/27/11 at 5:07

People deserve wealthy life time and loan or bank loan can make it much better. Just because people's freedom relies on money.

By: PattersonBetty18 on 8/20/11 at 4:36

If you want to buy real estate, you will have to receive the loan. Moreover, my mother usually uses a consolidation loan, which supposes to be the most useful.

By: Lawson23Rosella on 8/27/11 at 5:13

I took 1 st business loans when I was not very old and that supported my family a lot. Nevertheless, I require the student loan over again.

By: LindsayBobbi21 on 12/29/11 at 6:03

Buildings are not very cheap and not everybody can buy it. But, personal loans are created to help different people in such hard situations.