Analysis: Vanderbilt, Franklin discover nobody else cares about sex crime scandal

Friday, July 19, 2013 at 9:06am

HOOVER, Ala. - If he came here truly expecting outrage, maybe James Franklin is still learning about how a Southeastern Conference head football coach is truly measured.

Maybe he arrived the SEC Media Days circus girded with his most gracious but stern “no comment at this time.” Surely he assumed he’d face the inevitable pelting of questions about Vanderbilt’s confirmed dismissal of four players at the center of a sexual assault investigation for an alleged on-campus incident.

Or maybe he knew it would go down like it did. It took five questions — all from national or non-Nashville / Tennessee reporters — before anyone broached the subject. In front of hundreds of alleged journalists in the “main room” of the Media Days circus, the following topics, in order, were apparently more important than pressing for a comment on the sexual assault investigation:

— The challenge of opening the season in conference play vs. Ole Miss, on ESPN, in primetime

— Potentially playing home games at LP Field instead of Commodore Stadium

— The disadvantage of playing a bowl game in your home town

— The pressure to win in the SEC versus other BCS conferences

— Why Franklin turned down other coaching jobs to stay at Vandy

When it finally happened, only Nashville reporters asked about the dismissals and only Nashville reporters followed up on Franklin’s emphatic non-response on the grounds of “an ongoing investigation.” Within two minutes another reporter asked if there was a “friendly on-campus” rivalry with the equally successful Vandy baseball program.   

In other words, the rest of the nation of college football could care less. But did you hear the one about the college kid who slept through his alarm at the Manning Passing Academy? He won the Heisman — and more importantly, beat Alabama in Tuscaloosa last season — so for the last three days every terminally naïve columnist from Atlanta to Arkansas has opined upon the moral quandary that was Johnny Manziel’s fleeting weekend hangover.

More than a thousand sportswriter types beat their chests like grieving widows over Manziel’s garden variety teenage antics, yet the inarguably greater crime hanging over the Commodore football program was all but a momentary fart in the Wynfrey Hotel ballroom sandwiched between Paul Finebaum segments. Vanderbilt was worried enough to send their biggest gun — Beth Fortune, the university's vice chancellor for public affairs — along for her first (and last, she likely hopes) Media Days circus. She wasn't needed.

It’s understandable if you’re outraged by such a disproportionate response by the media, but if you’re angry in earnest, you don’t really understand the college football media: a potential Vanderbilt sex crime scandal didn’t figuratively rock Hoover because Vanderbilt football hasn’t literally rocked Alabama on the field.

It's the way of the South's great game: Win more and you'll be scorned more. For all of Franklin’s laying-of-hands upon one of Division 1 football’s most historically moribund brands, Vanderbilt is still 0-for-Forever against winning programs like Alabama, Georgia, South Carolina, LSU and Florida. At no point in the 'Dores recent run has one of their wins come at the expense of one of the league's (and subsequently the nation's) Tiffany programs. It might not make any moral sense, but that’s the only explanation as to why Manziel’s boozy snooze button controversy is a bigger talking point

Had the ‘Dores featured a Heisman winner these last two years, ESPN would be interviewing Metro Nashville investigators and assigning Roger Cossack to handicap potential plea deals for the four players. If you don’t believe me, roll the words “Johnny Manziel gang bang” around your mind and you’ll actually hear the sound of Skip Bayless’ voice on “First Take.”

Franklin and his brand of eager bravado are still a novelty item to the overwhelming majority of the college sports media. This is not by virtue of their upstart win/loss totals, but rather who those wins — and in this case, more importantly the losses — came against.

Franklin finished his segment in the main ballroom Friday without a notable remark. Minutes later, in a separate session with internet and radio media, the sexual assault was never even addressed, and after Franklin was whisked away for one-on-one sessions with ESPN, now an official SEC partner and the least likely candidate at the entire junket to discomfort a sitting conference head coach with pesky questions about criminal investigations.

Maybe Franklin expected more of even shake from the assembled SEC media. More bumps and bruises from moralizing reporters. More genuine scorn. And, conversely, a chance for Franklin himself to make a stand and point to his record, to explain the program’s alleged strict conduct policies and the fact the players were dismissed outright.

Or maybe the man who’s come to understand the short shrift afforded to Vanderbilt football in every single other arena knew that until he started coaching wins over Gators and Bulldogs and Gamecocks, an alleged gang rape is bad, but it’s not sleepy-Heisman-winner bad.

8 Comments on this post:

By: Bellevue on 7/19/13 at 8:01

One of the best articles ever written about Vanderbilt football.

That said, the media shares the persona that the majority of Nashville / Middle Tennessee residents do in that they could care less about Vanderbilt football as clearly evidence by their inability to only half fill a 40,000 seat stadium even after attending two bowl games for the first time in a hundred years.

Some people never look at themselves.

By: joe41 on 7/19/13 at 8:11

Only David Climer and his idiotic questions which were prepared three weeks in advance.


By: joe41 on 7/19/13 at 8:13

Bellevue, you should come attend one of Vanderbilt's games. You might find out how stupid your comments really are.

We always look at ourselves as well as others in our sphere of the world.


By: 4gold on 7/20/13 at 7:34

Yes, Bellevue. You are the reason Vanderbilt does not fill a 40,000 seat stadium in a city of 2 million. YOU don't support your home town sports. I suspect you are enjoying supporting a losing football program, non existant baseball program and everything else under NCAA investigation in east TN. Ancient history and Pillsbury Phil.

As for the SEC media a party and gang rape is old hat from where they come from. It is only new at Vandy and very disappointing.

Go Dores, Preds, Titans! Go Nashville a great place to live!

By: amyinsparta on 7/20/13 at 9:39

It could very well be that the type of student that goes to Vanderbilt is not, in general, the type of student who loves sports above all else. And so, that type of student grows into that type of adult who, on Saturdays, finds other things with which to amuse him/herself. Not everyone is in love with the sport nor the conference. It is what it is.

By: Badbob on 7/21/13 at 5:08

Amy, Exactly. Vandy students are more interested in learning which cheeses go with which wines, than watching football. That's why VU had to ban student parties before football games, so students would be sober enough to walk to the stadium.

4gold - you beat UT once in 30 years. Yeehaw. I got to the Vandy stadium one year just as Vandy was kicking off to UT. I stopped to get a hot dog and Coke at the concession stand and before we got seated, the score was UT 14 - Vandy 0. The only excitement in the game was if UT would put up triple digits... which I still hope to see once in my lifetime. :)

The article does miss one item. VU went to Tuscaloosa one year and beat Alabama at homecoming. I said at the time, Alabama coaches will play the highlights of that defeat before the Vandy game for the next 100 years and VU will get the crap kicked out of them by Bama year after year for embarrassing them at homecoming.

Just as soon as I get any sympathy, or respect for Vandy, along comes someone like 4gold, and I end up wishing nothing but the worst for VU. I asked a former VU basketball star one day, "What perks do you get from Vandy for being one of the top basketball stars for your 4 years of undergraduate work?" He said, "They let me get in line to buy basketball tickets just like everybody else." LOL, Vandy needs to look in the mirror instead of worrying about slamming anyone else.

By: courier37027 on 7/22/13 at 11:09

When the Tennessee game was played during Thanksgiving weekend, Vanderbilt strudents would sell their tickets to Vols fans. The good old days: when Alabama and Tennessee would make 2/3 of crowd at Dudley Field.

By: wiseguy1 on 7/23/13 at 7:53

Some folsk just won't be content. For the decades taht VU football has been less than competative on a weekly basis, VU fans suffere the scorn of many Tennessee residents for not being competative. Now that Vanderbilt football is competative on a weekly basis, the scorn remains, but for different reasons.

No matter what, some folks will always find a reason not to support Vanderbilt atletics.